Trading competitions: some thoughts & and a challenge
Hi There
My book Bird Watching in Lion Country (First Edition) and my mentoring programme produced three out of three top places in one of the most prestigious real money trading competitions around, the FX Street Forex Trader of the Year international trading competition.
In 2007, towards the the end of the trading competition, I was made aware of the fact that the leading two participants were actually readers of BWILC and one of them was on my mentor programme. Obviously I was delighted. They ended first and second. As a consequence I was invited to speak at the next (2008) FX Street Barcelona Traders’ conference. It was a privilege and a pleasure.
In 2009 FX Street asked me if I would offer some prizes for the competition and I offered two mentorships valued at $1,990 to the worst performers. Both those prize winners are now on my Class of 2010.
About two thirds through the 2009 competition one of my mentoring clients informed me that he was in the competition and doing well and he told me he thought he could win it. Five weeks later he was declared the winner.
I have ambivalent thoughts about trading competitions. On the one hand I think they are just part of a scheme to generate trades for brokers hard up for trades (and thus revenue). Obviously from a marketing-to-the-gullible point of view it makes sense to be able to say so-and-so has made a fortune in record time under the pressure of a competition (and therefore you can do it too).
This is the big negative of trading competitions: They are too short. Luck plays a disproportionate role. You can’t make any long term conclusions from such short term performance.
Nevertheless, I think anyone serious about making something of his trading should take a second look at a real money trading competition like the FX Street competition as it can tell you a lot about your current trading approach and the state of your progress as a trader.
A positive of these competitions are that they don’t ask a huge capital investment on a live account. This allows you to test the boundaries of your #1 trading system under pressure conditions. It’s important because even if you aren’t trading month-to-month to earn your living from trading, you will, due to short term goals, experience periods of stress and you will have to perform during these periods.
A trading competition shows you something of the flexibility of your system, how much room you have to move in it.
The simple but profound question it asks you is this:
Are you in charge of your trading system or is your trading system in charge of you?
Think about that.
Most people are actually victims of their trading systems which are ill-conceived with no foundation in reality.
Is your trading system flexible?
For Formula One drivers there is a specific optimal driving line around the course. The cars are highly competitive making the playing field as level as it can be. Yet each driver retains the choice, the flexibility of when and how to use gears, acceleration and brakes, and this makes a huge difference to the outcome. Michael Schumacher didn’t win because he had the best car by far. He won because his choices were the best – hundreds and hundreds of little choices that he stacked up and built into an unbeatable edge.
How’s your trading system? Do you have flexibility? Does it give you space? Do you have choices? What about small edges that can all add up to an ‘unbeatable’ system? Can you, like Martin, the winner of the 2009 FX Street competition, decide two weeks before the end of the competition to change gears to overtake the others and win? Or are you sitting, frustrated and confused, looking at the screen, hoping for the next big signal that will save you from ending at the back of the grid? Is the only flexibility in your system the flexibility of gambling with a bigger stop loss, exceeding your risk: reward ratio?
A trading competition in itself doesn’t add much value to most participants. But if you use a trading competition as a part of your process to become a good trader you actually make it work in your favour. A trading competition adds healthy pressure. You set out to perform well over a specified period of time. This should however be part of a continuing process. It should be a type of culmination of putting everything together for the first time and putting it to the test.
I advocate that most trading systems are rubbish and most traders are copping out from using the most powerful trade generator in existence: their own brains. People enter trading competitions with the idea to be lucky and win the first prize, usually with a highly leveraged approach (compounding the impact of luck vs skill).
That’s not what you should do. You should put what you have learned to the test.
I am prepared to put this theory and idea to the test during the 2010 FX Street “FX Trader of the Year 10th Edition” contest.
Like I have said, to the best of my knowledge three BWILC traders entered the real money FX Street competitions in previous years and they came 1st (2007), 2nd (2007) and 1st (2009).
So I was thinking.
Why not give a lot of people an incentive to learn the ropes, drop the losing systems they have been fooling around with and prove it for all and sundry that the 4×1 BWILC trading approach contains several edges which are applicable under real trading conditions. For instance its flexibility.
Due to the nature of these competitions there is an element of luck involved. So I am not saying the challenge is to win the competition. (After all there can only be one first prize winner.) But, there can be many winners! Those who use the competition to better their trading.
For me the challenge is to show that even if a number of BWILC based participants take part the majority of them will outperform the rest. During the 2007 and 2009 competition only the top two and top three respective participants had positive returns. That’s 0% + 0.0000001. What a joke. The rest were LOSERS with their fancy ’scientific’ 3:1 risk : rewards, positive expectancies, let your profits run, cut your losses and don’t risk more than 2% of your account on any single signal, systems.
This is a breakthrough insight I got from studying the trading history of several hundred losers (sorry guys, but you were!): They all trade the same way! They either had absolutely no clue as to what they were doing or they were applying the “#1″ loser system I have just described. The only difference was the duration. Some did it for a few months only and others for a few years. Some tried once or twice others tried dozens of systems – all end in the same manner. FAILURE.
WHY? WHY? That is the question that preoccupied me. The answer is simple. These systems are fatally flawed considering the nature and characteristics of currency price fluctuations.
Easy as that.
Garbage in … losses out!
The challenge for participants would be to stress test to what extent they ‘own their own brains’ and have flexibility, a definitive edge and a sustainable trading system after a period of development of such a system.
Quality in … profits out!
Regarding the 2010 FX STREET TRADER OF THE YEAR CONTEST, here’s the deal:
1. You register to take part in the live 2010 FX Street FX Trader of Year competition.
2. You open a real money trading account of $2,000 or more (this is the minimum for the competition) at a Forex Broker of my choice before the end of May 2010.
3. You buy BWILC 2010 or provide proof that you have a legitimate copy.
4. During the next few months, until the competition begins I help you to master the BWILC trading principles and you go out and use the FX Street FX Trader of the Year Competition to prove to yourself that you can do it. And maybe you can win some of the great prizes too.
Keep in mind I don’t expect of you to do anything if you don’t want to in terms of live trading before the competition starts. So that gives you four full months (May – August) to prepare. That is more than enough.
Let’s look at that again.
I am happy to dominate this years FX Street FX Trader of the Year competition based on the fact that my previous three clients I know about came 1st, 2nd and 1st in the respective years and prove that the BWILC, 4×1, median grid trading system is superior to the fatally flawed “systems” almost all losers use.
I am also confident that the average rookie BWILC trader can beat the FX Trader of the Year average (achieved by non-BWILC-based-traders). Thus I am offering an opportunity to anyone with an interest in becoming serious about his / her trading this year to enter the 2010 FX Street Trader of the Year Live Trading competition before the end of May 2010. Open an account at a broker nominated by me and I will put you (at no extra cost and with no obligations whatsoever) on a preparatory program to BEAT THE LOSERS HANDS DOWN.
Click on this link for more information about the Trader of the Year Opportunity
Ask your most pressing forex questions and get a personal response from DrForex.
Get your completely updated and expanded copy of Bird Watching in Lion Country 2010 here
If you are a legitimate owner of BWILC 1st Edition, you qualify for a deep discount on the updated and expanded BWILC 2010